The Real Reason America Doesn’t Have Enough Court Reporters

Posted bystenoimperiumPosted inCourt Reporting, Legal ServicesTags:, , , , , , , , , , , ,

A Comparative Journey with the Truck Driver Shortage

In recent years, the shortage of court reporters in the United States has become a critical issue, one that is slowly eroding the justice system’s efficiency and fairness. Court reporters are integral to maintaining the integrity of legal proceedings, producing accurate and timely transcripts that record the spoken word in a courtroom or deposition. But much like the ongoing shortage of truck drivers, the reasons behind the shortage of court reporters are more complex than simply not enough people entering the profession. This shortage is not driven by a lack of interest or training opportunities but by a job that is full of stress, physical deprivation, and increasing isolation—a job that, like truck driving, demands more than just technical skill.

The Vanishing Profession

The role of a court reporter is simple in theory but often demanding in practice. Court reporters, or stenographers, are tasked with creating a verbatim record of every statement made in a courtroom or legal proceeding. This requires a unique skill set, including proficiency in shorthand or stenotype machines, a high level of focus, and quick thinking. In an average day, a reporter may be responsible for transcribing the dialogue in fast-paced, high-stakes cases that demand accuracy down to the last punctuation mark. It’s a job that requires mental stamina, as court reporters must juggle the pressure of real-time transcription with the accuracy of their reports.

However, despite the critical nature of their work, the number of qualified court reporters has steadily dwindled in recent years. According to the National Court Reporters Association (NCRA), the number of court reporters in the United States has dropped by more than 30% in the last decade alone. This has led to an alarming backlog in cases, with many courts resorting to using less reliable alternatives like digital recordings or unqualified transcribers.

The shortage has not only affected courtrooms but has also contributed to delays in the judicial system, where victims and defendants alike suffer from the slow pace of proceedings. Yet, despite the increasing demand for these professionals, there is little movement to bridge the gap.

The Truck Driver Shortage: A Parallel Story

To better understand why America has a shortage of court reporters, one need only look to a similar shortage facing a different industry: truck driving. The truck driver shortage has reached critical levels, with over 78,000 positions currently unfilled, with experts predicting that the gap could reach 170,000 drivers by 2030. Like court reporting, the shortage isn’t because there’s a lack of training or certification opportunities. There’s simply no one willing to take on the job in sufficient numbers, and those who do often leave the profession early.

A deep dive into the truck driver shortage reveals an industry plagued by long hours, poor working conditions, low pay, and physical and mental exhaustion. Drivers spend weeks on the road, away from their families, often battling loneliness, isolation, and health issues. Their job requires constant vigilance behind the wheel, as they travel thousands of miles across the country under extreme pressure to meet deadlines. This stress takes a toll on their health, relationships, and well-being. It’s a job that, on the surface, seems straightforward: drive from point A to point B. But the reality of the job involves much more than that, and the mental and physical demands are far greater than most people are willing to accept.

Much like truck drivers, court reporters also face significant personal challenges. While their physical demands are less severe, they are often subjected to mental exhaustion and isolation. Court reporters spend long hours in courtrooms, alone in their task of capturing the exact words of each speaker, without interruption or opportunity for breaks. Their work demands immense concentration, and the pressures to keep up with the pace of a courtroom, especially in high-profile cases, can be overwhelming.

However, despite the difficulty of the profession, court reporters face increasing devaluation of their role. With the advent of digital recording technologies and voice recognition software, there is a growing trend in the legal industry to cut costs by replacing human reporters with machines. These technological advancements may seem like a cost-effective solution, but they fail to offer the level of accuracy, nuance, and clarity that human reporters can provide. And much like the trucking industry’s reliance on technology for long-haul transportation, there is a risk that over-reliance on technology may exacerbate the problem of accuracy and safety, leaving the industry vulnerable to greater challenges down the road.

Stress, Loneliness, and Growing Disrespect

The stresses and demands of both professions—the court reporter and the truck driver—are undeniable. Both fields require workers to spend long stretches of time away from home, endure physical and mental exhaustion, and navigate workplace environments that are often unrelenting and thankless.

For court reporters, there’s the constant pressure to keep up with the proceedings while ensuring that every word is captured with 100% accuracy. This requires a level of focus and dedication that many people simply aren’t willing to commit to. The loneliness and isolation of the job can also be profound. Many court reporters work independently, often traveling to different courthouses and working in rooms full of strangers. While their work is critical to the legal process, it often goes unnoticed, and they rarely receive the recognition they deserve.

Truck drivers face a similar sense of isolation on the road. Long hours away from family and friends, navigating unfamiliar routes, and dealing with unpredictable traffic and weather conditions make the job physically taxing and emotionally draining. The lack of respect from employers and the public is also a common complaint. Truck drivers often find themselves working for low wages, with little job security, and even less appreciation for the essential role they play in keeping the nation’s supply chains functioning.

Both professions also face a growing lack of respect for their skills. As new technologies and automation systems emerge, the role of human workers is becoming increasingly undervalued. For court reporters, the rise of digital transcription tools threatens to replace their invaluable expertise. For truck drivers, self-driving trucks and automated systems loom on the horizon, threatening to displace workers who have spent years perfecting their craft.

A Solution Staring Us in the Face

To combat these shortages, it is essential to recognize that the issue isn’t simply about finding new workers for these professions. The true problem lies in the systemic issues that make these careers unattractive or unsustainable.

For both truck drivers and court reporters, increasing respect for the profession and offering better work-life balance would go a long way toward making these careers more attractive. Additionally, raising pay, improving working conditions, and providing more recognition for their critical work could help stem the tide of attrition in both fields.

Just as the truck driver shortage has led to calls for better treatment and respect for drivers, similar changes need to occur in the court reporting world. This might mean better pay for reporters, more flexible schedules, and initiatives to raise awareness about the importance of their work. It could also mean better training opportunities and support networks for those entering the profession, ensuring that future court reporters are well-equipped to handle the emotional and mental demands of the job.

Conclusion

Both the truck driver and court reporter shortages stem from similar root causes: an overwhelming amount of stress, loneliness, and a general lack of respect for the essential roles these professionals play. By acknowledging these realities and addressing the underlying issues, America can begin to solve both shortages—ensuring that both legal and logistical systems continue to function effectively for years to come. Like truck drivers, court reporters are integral to the smooth running of the country’s most important systems. Without them, we risk a breakdown of the very foundations that keep our nation moving forward.

Published by stenoimperium

We exist to facilitate the fortifying of the Stenography profession and ensure its survival for the next hundred years! As court reporters, we've handed the relationship role with our customers, or attorneys, over to the agencies and their sales reps.  This has done a lot of damage to our industry.  It has taken away our ability to have those relationships, the ability to be humanized and valued.  We've become a replaceable commodity. Merely saying we are the “Gold Standard” tells them that we’re the best, but there are alternatives.  Who we are though, is much, much more powerful than that!  We are the Responsible Charge.  “Responsible Charge” means responsibility for the direction, control, supervision, and possession of stenographic & transcription work, as the case may be, to assure that the work product has been critically examined and evaluated for compliance with appropriate professional standards by a licensee in the profession, and by sealing and signing the documents, the professional stenographer accepts responsibility for the stenographic or transcription work, respectively, represented by the documents and that applicable stenographic and professional standards have been met.  This designation exists in other professions, such as engineering, land surveying, public water works, landscape architects, land surveyors, fire preventionists, geologists, architects, and more.  In the case of professional engineers, the engineering association adopted a Responsible Charge position statement that says, “A professional engineer is only considered to be in responsible charge of an engineering work if the professional engineer makes independent professional decisions regarding the engineering work without requiring instruction or approval from another authority and maintains control over those decisions by the professional engineer’s physical presence at the location where the engineering work is performed or by electronic communication with the individual executing the engineering work.” If we were to adopt a Responsible Charge position statement for our industry, we could start with a draft that looks something like this: "A professional court reporter, or stenographer, is only considered to be in responsible charge of court reporting work if the professional court reporter makes independent professional decisions regarding the court reporting work without requiring instruction or approval from another authority and maintains control over those decisions by the professional court reporter’s physical presence at the location where the court reporting work is performed or by electronic communication with the individual executing the court reporting work.” Shared purpose The cornerstone of a strategic narrative is a shared purpose. This shared purpose is the outcome that you and your customer are working toward together. It’s more than a value proposition of what you deliver to them. Or a mission of what you do for the world. It’s the journey that you are on with them. By having a shared purpose, the relationship shifts from consumer to co-creator. In court reporting, our mission is “to bring justice to every litigant in the U.S.”  That purpose is shared by all involved in the litigation process – judges, attorneys, everyone.  Who we are is the Responsible Charge.  How we do that is by Protecting the Record.

Leave a comment